Lemon Squeezy Alternatives After the Shutdown: Fees on a $1,000 Month and Three Checkouts Tested
Lemon Squeezy stops processing payments on March 31, 2027. Here is what each alternative costs on a $1,000 month and what our sandbox checkouts showed.
Updated November 18, 2026: rewritten after Lemon Squeezy announced its shutdown. The dates, every fee and the picks were checked on each vendor's own page on November 18, 2026, and the checkout results come from our sandbox test of October 21 and 22, 2026.
Lemon Squeezy is closing. New store sign-ups stopped on November 16, 2026, and payment processing stops on March 31, 2027, subscription renewals included. Lemon Squeezy says it won't extend that date (announcement, migration guide, both checked November 18, 2026).
So this isn't a "should I leave" post anymore. You're leaving. The open question is where to, and the default answer Lemon Squeezy gives you, Stripe Managed Payments, drops four things Lemon Squeezy did for you.
How we tested: Three sandboxes, Polar, Paddle and Creem, got the same $50 a month product in October 2026. We opened each hosted checkout as a buyer in Germany and in the United States, stopping before any payment. The checkout screenshots below are our own.
What are the dates, and what does Lemon Squeezy want you to do?

Four dates, all from the migration guide:
- November 16, 2026. No new users or stores.
- December 2, 2026. Migration tooling for Stripe Managed Payments opens at app.lemonsqueezy.com/migration, for eligible stores.
- Mid-January 2027. The latest start Lemon Squeezy recommends, because the full move "can take up to 8 weeks".
- March 31, 2027. Processing stops.
Lemon Squeezy recommends Managed Payments, Stripe's own Merchant of Record product. That was already the direction a month before the announcement. When we tried to open a Lemon Squeezy store on October 22, the sign-up flow told us "Managed Payments is the best fit" and made us answer a required question, "Why are you choosing Lemon Squeezy?", before it showed the register form.

What do you lose if you follow Lemon Squeezy to Stripe Managed Payments?
We haven't tested Managed Payments hands-on. We only got as far as Stripe's sign-up form, so everything in this section comes from Lemon Squeezy's and Stripe's own pages.
Lemon Squeezy's comparison page (checked November 18, 2026) lists what Managed Payments doesn't include:
- PayPal. Not supported. PayPal subscriptions can't migrate, and those customers have to subscribe again with another payment method.
- File delivery and license keys. Not included. You connect a fulfillment app or build it.
- Affiliates. Not included. Lemon Squeezy points you to Dub, a separate affiliate platform.
- Storefront and email marketing. Not included.
Then there's eligibility. Your business has to be based in one of 37 countries: the United States, Canada, 31 European countries, Australia, Hong Kong, Japan and Singapore (Stripe eligibility, checked November 18, 2026). India, Pakistan, Brazil and Turkey aren't on the list. If you're outside it, Lemon Squeezy says it can't move your account and you'll need another provider.
And the price. Managed Payments costs 3.5% per transaction on top of Stripe's processing fees, and Stripe Billing fees apply to subscriptions (Stripe pricing, checked November 18, 2026). Migrating merchants get 1.5% instead of 3.5% through December 1, 2027. After that date you pay more than you paid Lemon Squeezy, as the table below shows.
What you do get is the only self-serve tooling for the subscriptions themselves. From December 2 it migrates most card subscriptions without customers typing their card again, with at least 14 days' notice to each customer.
What does each alternative cost on a $1,000 month?
One workload, priced from each vendor's published rates. Twenty subscription payments of $50, all on US cards, no sales tax. The Stripe rows use the rates for a US Stripe account. This is arithmetic from the pricing pages, not a test.
| Provider | Published rate (checked November 18, 2026) | Fees on $1,000 | PayPal | License keys |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lemon Squeezy (until March 31, 2027) | 5% + $0.50, plus 0.5% on subscriptions | $65 | Yes | Yes |
| Creem | 3.9% + $0.40 | $47 | No | Yes |
| Dodo Payments | 4% + $0.40, plus 0.5% on subscriptions | $53 | Yes, +3% | Yes |
| Polar | 5% + $0.50 on the free Starter plan | $60 | No | Yes |
| Paddle | 5% + $0.50 | $60 | Yes | Build it yourself |
| Stripe Managed Payments, promotional | 1.5% + Stripe's 2.9% + $0.30 + 0.7% Billing | $57 | No | Not included |
| Stripe Managed Payments, standard | 3.5% + Stripe's 2.9% + $0.30 + 0.7% Billing | $77 | No | Not included |
The arithmetic, so you can swap in your own numbers:
- Polar Starter, Paddle: $1,000 × 5% = $50, plus 20 × $0.50 = $10.
- Lemon Squeezy: $1,000 × 5.5% = $55, plus 20 × $0.50 = $10.
- Creem: $1,000 × 3.9% = $39, plus 20 × $0.40 = $8.
- Dodo: $1,000 × 4.5% = $45, plus 20 × $0.40 = $8.
- Managed Payments, standard: $35 (3.5%) + $29 (2.9%) + $6 (20 × $0.30) + $7 (0.7% Billing).
- Managed Payments, promotional: the same with $15 (1.5%) in place of $35.
Three things move those totals. Cards from outside the US add 1.5% on Lemon Squeezy, on Polar, on Dodo and on both Stripe rows (Stripe's international card fee for a US account), so $15 more on this month if every buyer is abroad. Creem's pricing page says "No international card fees", and Paddle's lists no surcharge. Payouts cost extra on three of them. Creem charges $7 or 1% per bank payout, whichever is higher (Creem payouts, checked November 18, 2026). Polar passes on Stripe's payout fees of $2 a month plus 0.25% + $0.25 per payout. Dodo's pricing page lists $5 on a payout under $1,000 and $25 for a USD SWIFT payout to a business outside the US. And Polar's $20 Pro plan (3.8% + $0.40) would cost $66 here. Polar puts its break-even at about $1,379 a month in sales.
Polar: $5 less than Lemon Squeezy on our month, and the subscription import isn't settled
In the sandbox, Polar asked for the least before a checkout worked. Sign-up took an email and a code, onboarding asked for an organization name, a currency and a terms checkbox, and the product was saved 14 seconds after onboarding finished.
The German checkout kept the price at $50 and showed $7.98 as "Taxes (included)". The US checkout added $4.44 on top, for $54.44. The terms line under the Subscribe button names "Polar Software, Inc., our online reseller and merchant of record".

Before live payments, Polar's Account Review page asks for an identity check ("Takes ~5 min with a photo ID"), a payout account, a description of what you sell and your website, then a review by Polar's team. We didn't start that review.
For Lemon Squeezy merchants, Polar's own migration page (checked November 18, 2026) is candid about what isn't ready. Polar says it's "in conversation with Lemon Squeezy" about taking over active subscriptions without customers re-entering cards, and recommends waiting before you pick a destination in Lemon Squeezy's migration form. It's also "looking into" carrying existing license keys over unchanged. New sales can move today, and Polar issues license keys for those. There's no PayPal, and no timeline for it.
One warning if you sell an AI product. Polar's acceptable use policy, effective October 1, 2026, puts "AI Content Generation tools (text, image, video, voice)" in the group that needs a closer review and may not be accepted. We compared six providers on that question in which payment providers accept AI image and video apps.
Creem: $18 cheaper than Lemon Squeezy on our month, but German buyers saw $59.50
Creem has the lowest published rate here without a monthly fee, and its product page did the math for us. For our $50 product it showed "$47.65 per sale after 3.9% + $0.40 fee".
The checkout behaved differently from the other two. For the German buyer, Creem added 19% VAT on top of the price, so $50.00 + $9.50 = $59.50. Polar and Paddle kept the German total at $50 and took the tax out of it. For the US buyer with a full New York address, Creem showed no tax line and a $50 total, where Polar and Paddle both added $4.44. Those were the defaults in our test accounts, and we didn't look for a tax-inclusive setting on Creem. Check it before you move EU customers, because a silent 19% price rise is a bad way to announce a migration.

One thing tripped us up. Sign-up itself was quick, a magic link with no password that arrived in 2 seconds. But the dashboard opened in live mode with a test-mode banner showing, so our first product was a live one and its link failed with "Account Verification Required". We had to switch to test mode and create it again.
Creem is going after Lemon Squeezy stores directly, with 0 processing fees for the first month and a migration its team runs for you (offer, checked November 18, 2026). Read the migration guide (checked November 18, 2026) before you count on it. Products, discount codes and customers move. Active subscriptions, saved cards and existing license keys don't. Each subscriber checks out once on Creem, close to their renewal date, and a direct import is "in development". Creem issues license keys and delivers files for new sales, doesn't take PayPal, and pays out to merchants in 87 countries. Revenue splits cost an extra 2% (split payments, checked November 18, 2026).
We put Polar, Lemon Squeezy and Creem side by side earlier in Polar vs Lemon Squeezy vs Creem.
Paddle: the only tested checkout with PayPal, and the most setup
Paddle asked for the most at sign-up: name, password, business name and type, annual revenue, country and a full address. Polar and Creem asked for an email and a few store details.
The checkout matched Polar's tax handling. For Germany it showed $42.02 plus $7.98 tax, a $50.00 total. For the United States it showed $50.00 plus $4.44, a $54.44 total. The German checkout's footer reads "Sold by paddle 30 Old Bailey, London", and the US one names a New York address. And the sandbox checkout showed a PayPal button next to Card, which Polar's checkout didn't have. We stopped Creem's checkout before the payment step, and its migration guide says it doesn't take PayPal.

A Paddle checkout needs an approved domain. The hosted checkout we used worked freely in the sandbox, but the same page says that in live accounts hosted checkouts are "only available for an app-to-web sales funnel, or for embedding the checkout in a non-mobile app such as a desktop application", by request. So plan on embedding Paddle's checkout in your own site. Going live means a separate live account, recreating the catalog, and domain approval. The sandbox has no identity check page, so we didn't see what the live account asks for.
If you sell license keys, know that Paddle Billing doesn't issue them. Paddle's developer docs (checked November 18, 2026) say fulfillment on Billing means building "your own workflows using transaction webhooks". At 5% + $0.50 it has Lemon Squeezy's base rate, with no subscription surcharge. We compared it with Stripe in Lemon Squeezy vs Stripe vs Paddle.
Dodo Payments: for businesses outside the 37 countries
We haven't tested Dodo Payments hands-on, because it wasn't in our October sandbox task. It's here because of who it serves. If your business is in India or another country Managed Payments doesn't support, Dodo is a Merchant of Record built for that case, at 4% + $0.40 for US cards, plus 1.5% for international cards and 0.5% on subscriptions (Dodo pricing, checked November 18, 2026). Its pricing page lists UPI, SEPA Direct Debit and PayPal (3% extra), and its docs cover license keys, checked November 18, 2026. Dodo also documents a Lemon Squeezy import, which we haven't tried. Its dodo-migrate lemonsqueezy tool (checked November 18, 2026) copies products, customers, discount codes and existing license key strings, and customers re-activate their keys afterwards. It doesn't move subscriptions or saved cards. For those, Dodo describes a card import run with its support team (checked November 18, 2026).
Which one should you move to?
You sell subscriptions on cards, you're in a supported country, and you don't use license keys or affiliates. Take the Managed Payments migration. It's the only route with announced tooling that moves card subscriptions without your customers typing a card again (it opens December 2), and the 1.5% rate holds until December 1, 2027. Put a reminder in your calendar for that date, because $57 becomes $77.
You sell a desktop app or plugin with license keys. Managed Payments and Paddle Billing both leave licensing to you. Creem and Polar issue keys for new sales, but neither moves your existing keys today. Dodo documents an import of existing key strings, which we haven't tested. Don't pick a destination until you've seen your keys survive a test import, or until Lemon Squeezy publishes the fulfillment guidance it has promised closer to the tooling release on December 2.
Your business is outside the 37 countries. Creem (87 payout countries), Polar or Dodo. Check your country on each list first (Polar, Creem, Dodo, all checked November 18, 2026), because they differ. Dodo's list doesn't include Pakistan, for example. Fill in Lemon Squeezy's migration intake form, since only card subscriptions can be handed to another provider. If Polar is on your list, it asks you to wait before naming a destination.
A lot of your subscribers pay with PayPal. They have to subscribe again wherever you go. Paddle and Dodo let them keep paying with PayPal.
You want the lowest fee and you're starting fresh. Creem, at $47 on our $1,000 month. Check the VAT display first.
Whatever you choose, move new sales now and leave existing subscribers renewing on Lemon Squeezy until the import question is answered. Both Polar and Creem describe that split in their own guides. If you'd rather drop the Merchant of Record model and handle tax yourself, we cover that in Stripe alternatives. Tell us what you picked on X at @devtoolpicks.
Frequently Asked Questions
What happens to my Lemon Squeezy license keys after March 31, 2027?
Nothing changes before that date. After it, Lemon Squeezy says customers may lose access to license keys, files and download links unless you have moved your historical orders to a new fulfillment tool. Stripe Managed Payments does not issue or check keys, so you connect a licensing app or build your own. Polar says it is looking into bringing existing keys over unchanged. Creem lists existing keys among the things that do not move today. Dodo Payments documents an import of key strings, which we have not tested.
Can I use Lemon Squeezy for Kick streaming payouts?
No, and since November 16, 2026 you cannot open a new Lemon Squeezy store at all. If you build software or tools that Kick creators buy, a Merchant of Record such as Polar, Creem or Paddle can take those payments, collect the tax and pay you out. If you are a streamer who wants Kick earnings paid through another platform, none of these tools do that.
Get honest tool comparisons in your inbox
Join 50+ indie hackers and solo developers who get new comparisons, pricing changes, and tool picks. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Related Articles
Best Invoicing Tools for Indie Hackers in 2026
Three genuinely different invoicing tools, and the honest case for not buying on...
Best Stripe Alternatives for Indie Hackers in 2026 (Honest Picks)
Stripe is powerful but it can close accounts without warning, does nothing about...
Polar vs Lemon Squeezy vs Creem in 2026: Which MoR Is Right for Indie Hackers?
Lemon Squeezy was the indie hacker favourite. Then Stripe bought it. Polar and C...